Free Reads

Back to Library >
ti icon

Free Reads

Man Maths: Jaguar F-Type

4 months ago

not bookmarked

Writer:

Dan Prosser | Ti co-founder

Date:

31 August 2024

The older I get, the less I seem to worry about the objective markers of a car’s quality. Which is just a pompous way of saying I increasingly like cars that make me feel good. I’ll take an unforgettable driving experience over perfectly polished ride and handling characteristics, thanks very much.

Which is why the Jaguar F-Type is looking more and more appealing. I’ve written plenty of F-Type reviews in the past criticising their overly light and hyperactive steering, their slightly loose body control and the shonkier aspects of their interiors. They’re all very fair criticisms that should be made. But on every occasion, I’ve made my admiration for Jaguar’s Porsche 911 rival known too.

I remember going on the original media launch in northern Spain 12 years ago. The convertible arrived first and I spent two very happy days blasting around that deserted corner of the continent, roof down, hearing the F-Type’s clattering V6 and thunderous V8 soundtracks spill out across the landscape, or ricochet off a rock face and fire right back at me. I shared a car with Jaguar’s ride and handling Yoda, Mike Cross, swapping seats as we went.

The coupé is prettier than the convertible, reckons Prosser

But it’s the coupé that I covet now, mostly for the looks, particularly from the rear three-quarters. If you can look past the scratchy plastics, flaky switchgear and frankly inadequate infotainment system, the F-Type’s interior becomes a great place from which to watch a road disappear beneath that long bonnet.

The F-Type was compromised from day one. It was based on a cut down XK platform, meaning it was effectively seven years old before it had reached its first birthday. The aluminium body should have made it lighter than some rivals, but whenever I’ve weighed these cars they’ve been heavier than advertised. I suppose if you hang a load of heavy steel off an aluminium structure, the weight saving benefits will be wiped out.

Yes, the V8 is the one you want...

Because the F-Type was developed on a budget, or built to a cost, or possibly both. In too many ways, it shows. The V6 engines, for instance, are really just V8s with two pistons whipped out, the cylinders blanked off and the camshafts cut down accordingly. The engine block itself is no smaller.

But even with one hand tied behind its back, Jaguar built a great sports car. Of course it’s the 500bhp V8 that you want nowadays, partly for the performance and the noise, but also because they can turn their rear tyres from a solid to a gas at will. The four-wheel drive version that followed a few years later was objectively better by far, but that over-engined hotrod feel of the RWD car does make for a memorable drive.

The trouble is, the cheapest V8s are still £10,000 more expensive than the cheapest V6 S models, which themselves are not exactly under-endowed with 380bhp (like the V8s they’re supercharged too). I found several good examples for less than £20,000, the most affordable significantly so. If I had the money I’d take a V8 every time, but until then, I’d be quite happy tearing about the place in a V6 F-Type. Mine would be dark in colour with silver wheels and no brightwork – as good as the F-Type ever looked, in my view.

...but don't discount the V6 S

What’s equally appealing about these cars is that their mechanicals are so tried and tested I don’t think you’d worry about them at all. An Aston Martin V8 Vantage of similar vintage would cause you many more sleepless nights, I’m sure. And as I get older, considerations like that seem to become more and more important.

Free Reads on The Intercooler are freely available for all to read. The vast majority of our stories, including all of our feature articles, sit behind the paywall, only available to subscribers who get unlimited access to our ever-growing library of more than a thousand stories and close to two million words. 

Click here to try The Intercooler completely free for three weeks, with no credit card and no commitment, and gain full access to our multi award-winning website and app.